Case Study: Restructuring Stoned Fruit's Offers, Pricing, and Business Positioning

Client: Rebecca Gunter, Stoned Fruit
Business: Positioning and messaging studio
Service: Queens of Coin — Pricing and Offer Diagnostic
Focus: Offer architecture, strategic pricing, positioning, and separating studio services from Rebecca-led work

The Challenge: When Your Offer Structure No Longer Reflects the Business You Want to Run

Stoned Fruit had always been rooted in positioning and messaging. That was the work at the centre of the business, even when the studio was offering other services around it.

Over time, those services had expanded to include marketing work, website copy, brand strategy, case studies, expert papers, AI projects, and custom engagements. And while Stoned Fruit could do those things, Rebecca and the studio had reached a decision.

They didn't want to keep doing all of them.

Specifically, they wanted to move away from marketing services and make positioning and messaging the obvious focus of what Stoned Fruit offered.

The problem was figuring out how to make that transition visible.

Because when I looked at the existing offer menu, there were a lot of different things a buyer could purchase. Each service made sense individually, but together they made the studio look broader and more scattered than the business Rebecca wanted it to be.

And there was another consideration that made this more than a straightforward offer-cleanup exercise.

Rebecca wanted to eventually step away from the studio and focus on her own work.

She had expertise, opportunities, and strategic engagements that were tied specifically to her judgment and involvement. But those were sitting alongside Stoned Fruit's services, without a clear distinction between what belonged to the studio and what belonged to Rebecca herself.

So I wasn't just looking at how to organize a list of offers.

I needed to understand what Stoned Fruit should continue doing, what it should stop presenting as a service, and what needed to exist separately so Rebecca could pursue her own direction.

The Offer Audit: Two Different Businesses Were Being Presented as One

When I started looking at the offers, something became pretty clear.

Stoned Fruit already had a strategic foundation. The studio helped businesses understand, articulate, and apply their positioning and messaging. Sometimes that work resulted in a Brand Booklet. Sometimes it was a website, a case study, an expert paper, or another asset.

But those weren't necessarily separate categories of expertise. They were different ways of using the same positioning and messaging foundation.

The problem was that the offer menu didn't make that relationship obvious.

A buyer could see the things Stoned Fruit produced, but not necessarily understand the strategic process connecting them. That made the business look like it offered a collection of services rather than a clear progression of work.

I also found that some of the highest-value engagements didn't really belong in the studio's ordinary offer structure.

Rebecca's enterprise strategy, AI work, and custom advisory engagements depended heavily on her personal expertise. A buyer pursuing that work wasn't necessarily looking to hire a positioning and messaging studio.

They were looking to work with Rebecca.

And if the long-term goal was for Rebecca to step away from Stoned Fruit, keeping all of that work under the studio created a problem.

How could she build something of her own if the work people wanted her for was still being sold as part of the business she wanted to leave?

That was an important distinction I needed to make.

The Pricing Analysis: Why Adding Another Offer Wasn't the Answer

The original offer structure had another issue.

At the lower end, Stoned Fruit offered a 60-minute Problem Solving call for $375 and a 90-minute Brand Therapy session for $550. The next major step was a $5,500 positioning engagement.

That's quite a jump.

And because the two calls were priced so closely together, it wasn't particularly obvious why someone would choose one over the other beyond the amount of time they received.

I considered whether the business needed a new offer somewhere in the middle. A $2,500 DIY or intermediate service was one possibility.

But as I looked more closely at the work, I realized that adding another offer wasn't necessarily going to solve anything.

The existing calls already had different purposes. Problem Solving was intended for one contained issue, while Brand Therapy was a deeper strategic engagement for more interconnected questions.

They didn't need another product between them. They needed clearer roles and pricing that reflected the work involved.

The diagnostic recommended moving Problem Solving from $375 to $500 and Brand Therapy from $550 to $1,250.

I also looked at how other services were priced, including the difference between producing an asset and providing the strategic thinking that made that asset useful.

But the bigger question wasn't simply whether individual prices should go up.

It was whether the offers, their prices, and the way they were presented reflected the business Rebecca actually wanted to operate.

The Offer Architecture Recommendations: What Needed to Change

Make Positioning and Messaging the Focus of Stoned Fruit's Services

I didn't need to reposition Stoned Fruit as something it had never been. I needed to make the work it had always been doing much more obvious.

That meant moving away from presenting the studio as a broad marketing and creative-services business and centring its public-facing offers on positioning and messaging.

I organized the work into a clearer progression:

Talk It Through → Define It → Build From It

Talk It Through covered direct strategic conversations through Problem Solving and Brand Therapy. Define It centred the positioning and messaging engagements, where clients worked through the foundation of how their business should be understood and communicated. Build From It covered the assets that applied those decisions, including websites, case studies, expert papers, and other scoped work.

This gave the existing offers different jobs within the same business. Instead of treating every deliverable as an independent service, the structure made it easier to understand how the work connected.

And importantly, it made positioning and messaging the thing buyers encountered first.

Stop Selling Every Service the Studio Was Capable of Delivering

This was a big part of the conversation.

Because being capable of providing a service doesn't mean it needs to remain part of your business model.

Stoned Fruit had done marketing work. That didn't mean it had to keep selling marketing services simply because it had the skills, experience, or existing offers to do so.

I needed to separate the work the studio wanted to be known for from the work it had accumulated over time.

That also meant reconsidering how individual deliverables were presented.

For example, the Brand Booklet wasn't the strategic product on its own. It was the documentation of the positioning and messaging decisions reached through the engagement. Similarly, website copy, case studies, and expert papers could be understood as applications of that positioning rather than unrelated services.

The goal wasn't to make the business look smaller for the sake of simplicity.

It was to make the public-facing offer structure accurately reflect what Stoned Fruit wanted to sell.

Separate Rebecca's Personal Advisory Work From the Studio's Offers

This was probably the most important distinction for Rebecca's longer-term goals.

Some engagements belonged to Stoned Fruit because they were studio services that could be delivered through its positioning and messaging process. Other engagements belonged to Rebecca because the buyer was specifically purchasing her judgment, authority, and involvement.

That included higher-value enterprise strategy, AI-related strategic work, and custom advisory engagements.

I recommended giving those services a separate home under Rebecca Gunter rather than keeping them inside Stoned Fruit's ordinary offer menu.

And this wasn't just about pricing them differently. It was about recognizing that the two businesses needed to serve different purposes.

Stoned Fruit needed an offer structure built around the studio's work. Rebecca needed room to develop her own professional practice without every opportunity automatically becoming another Stoned Fruit service.

If she wanted to eventually step away from the studio, that separation was necessary.

Otherwise, she could keep building more opportunities for herself while simultaneously making the studio more dependent on her.

Which would be a pretty inconvenient way to accomplish the goal of leaving it.

The Results: Restructuring Stoned Fruit's Public-Facing Offers

One of the things I'm particularly proud of with this engagement is that I didn't stop at identifying what needed attention.

I followed through.

Stoned Fruit's front-facing offer structure was changed to centre positioning and messaging, rather than continuing to present the full collection of marketing and creative services it had previously offered.

I worked through what belonged in that public-facing studio structure and what needed to be treated separately as Rebecca-led work.

The business didn't need another offer to make the pricing progression work. It didn't need a completely new identity. And Rebecca didn't need to keep every service she'd ever offered attached to the studio simply because it had been there before.

I used what I found to make decisions about the structure. Then I put those decisions into practice.

That doesn't mean Rebecca has already stepped away from Stoned Fruit, or that the work of building her own practice is finished.

It means I made structural changes that support the direction she wants to move in.

And that's a meaningful outcome in its own right.

Why Business Problems Need More Than Generic Pricing and Offer Advice

There's a tendency in online business to look at a problem and immediately start suggesting things to add, remove, or rebuild.

Too many offers? Cut some. Big pricing gap? Create a middle offer. Unclear positioning? Rebrand. Want to step away from your business? Hire people and delegate.

And listen, sometimes those are perfectly reasonable recommendations.

But based on what?

Because if I'd approached Stoned Fruit that way, I could have ended up solving the wrong problem.

I could have created another offer to bridge the pricing gap, even though the existing services needed clearer roles and more appropriate pricing. I could have recommended a complete repositioning exercise, even though Stoned Fruit already knew what it was and had been doing that work for years.

Or I could have focused entirely on making the studio more profitable without considering that Rebecca's goal was to eventually step away from it.

That last part is particularly important.

Because a recommendation can make perfect sense for the business on paper and still work against what the person running it is trying to accomplish.

If I'd kept building every high-value opportunity into Stoned Fruit, I might have made the studio's offer menu more impressive. But I also could have made it harder for Rebecca to separate herself from the business.

And that would have been a pretty significant thing to overlook.

The Outcome: A Clearer Business Structure Without Rebuilding Everything

Stoned Fruit was already a positioning and messaging studio. Rebecca already had expertise and opportunities that extended beyond the studio's core services.

What I needed to do was understand how those things should be organized so they could support the direction she wanted to go.

I looked at the offers, pricing, buyer progression, and the difference between studio-delivered work and Rebecca-led engagements. I identified where the public-facing structure wasn't reflecting the actual business and made changes based on those findings.

I can't tell you that this work has produced a particular revenue increase or that Rebecca has completed her transition out of the studio.

Those aren't outcomes I'm claiming.

What I can say is that I clarified what Stoned Fruit would put front and centre, made decisions about which work belonged where, and followed through with restructuring its public-facing offers.

I wasn't trying to build Rebecca a bigger job inside the studio. I was trying to make room for the work she wanted to do outside of it.

And that required understanding the business before deciding what to change.

Sometimes the offer isn't wrong. Its role in the business is unclear. Sometimes the price isn't the only issue. It's how the buyer understands the difference between one engagement and another.

Sometimes a business doesn't need a new identity. It needs to make its existing identity more visible.

And sometimes the recommendations that would grow a business aren't necessarily the ones that support the person who owns it.

Get a Reality Check Before Changing Your Offers, Pricing, or Business Model

Reality Check — The Diagnostic ($997) is a standalone gap analysis between the business you're currently operating, the outcomes you want, and the resources and capacity you have available.

I examine the relevant parts of your business, identify what's actually happening, and develop recommendations based on the evidence rather than starting with a predetermined solution.

That might mean changing an offer, reconsidering pricing, adjusting delivery, or making a structural decision that affects how the business operates. It might also mean recognizing that something you've been thinking about changing doesn't need to change at all.

The point is to understand what you're working with before deciding what comes next.

Because I don't want to help you build a business that looks better on paper but takes you further away from the life and work you're trying to create.

Before you change the thing, let's make sure it's the thing.

Previous
Previous

case study: From Second-Guessing Her Pricing to Making Informed Business Decisions: McKayla's Story

Next
Next

What If My Real Constraints Mean I Can't Have the Business or Income I Want?